نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
Introduction: This research aims to address a critical gap in the field of Islamic-Iranian public administration. While existing scholarship bifurcates into critical, problem-focused studies of Iran's governance challenges and holistic theoretical works on Islamic management principles, there is a lack of systematic, normative ideal-building rooted in indigenous spiritual traditions. In response, this study seeks to revive and reconstruct the conceptual ideal of "Broad Authority" or Jāh-e ʿArīḍ from the Shi'i supplication "ʿĀliyat al-Maḍāmīn." The central purpose is to formulate a coherent, value-based framework for public administration in Iran that is simultaneously anchored in Islamic-Iranian tradition and responsive to contemporary governance issues such as corruption, inefficiency, and the theory-practice divide. By delving into this rich devotional text, the study proposes "Broad Authority" not as mere worldly power, but as a moral and managerial capacity for extensive, positive influence.
Methodology: Employing a qualitative research design within an interpretive paradigm, this study was conducted in two consecutive phases. In the first phase, using the method of implication analysis (dalālat-pazhūhī), the matching, implicative, and contextual implications of the text of ʿĀliyat al-Maḍāmīn, attributed to Imam Zayn al-ʿĀbidīn (AS), were extracted and validated in relation to the concept of Jāh-e ʿArīḍ. In the second phase, the extracted data were coded, categorized, and networked through Braun and Clarke’s (2006) six-phase thematic analysis. The supplication was purposively selected because of its canonical status in Shiʿi spirituality and its explicit focus on authority and governance. Initial coding yielded 25 implication-codes (e.g., “request for broad authority,” “enduring dignity,” “inner purity,” “foresight”). Trustworthiness was strengthened through peer review by experts in public administration and Islamic sciences, a detailed audit trail, and inter-coder reliability (Cohen’s Kappa = 0/87).
Findings: The thematic analysis revealed a sophisticated, four-dimensional model of "Broad Authority" (Jāh-e ʿArīḍ) as an administrative ideal:
- The Nature and Indicators of Broad Authority: This dimension outlines the essential characteristics of ideal authority: extensive influence and enduring dignity (wide acceptance and impact resistant to temporal fluctuations), magnanimity and independence (freedom from demeaning dependence on patronage or corrupt networks), and positive and escalating impact (authority that generates increasing public good and trust).
- The Ethical and Ontological Foundations of Authority-Holding: This dimension specifies the inner virtues and dispositions required of a manager: inner integrity and aversion to vice (purity from corruption and sin), wisdom and forbearance (practical intellect and capacity to handle criticism and conflict), good temperament and propriety (humility and respect in conduct), compassion and empathy (an active, caring concern for the welfare of the public), and reliance on God (viewing authority as a divine trust and depending on spiritual support).
- Institutionalized Commitments: This dimension articulates the inherent duties attached to a position of authority: safeguarding trusts and boundaries (protecting public resources and private spheres from abuse), standing firm against corruption and tyranny (actively resisting unjust internal and external pressures), and foresight and ultimate accountability (planning for long-term consequences and being answerable for final outcomes).
- The Ultimate Transcendent Purpose: The final dimension establishes the higher meaning of authority: viewing authority as a means for drawing closer to God. This teleological perspective sanctifies administrative work, framing leadership as a form of social worship and service to God's creation.
These dimensions are dynamically interrelated, forming a holistic "virtue cycle" where ethical foundations enable committed action, which in turn cultivates legitimate authority, all directed towards a transcendent goal.
Discussion & Conclusion: This study bridges the identified research gap by offering a substantive, indigenous ideal for Iranian public administration derived from a key Shiʿi spiritual source. The reconstructed concept of “Broad Authority” (Jāh-e ʿArīḍ) provides a powerful normative response to the functional and legitimacy crises documented in critical literature. It enriches theoretical discourse on Islamic public administration by moving beyond abstract principles to model concrete ethical virtues and institutional commitments. The proposed four-dimensional model offers a comprehensive framework for reimagining systems of training, selection, and evaluation for public administrators. It advocates a managerial ethos integrating moral competence, social responsibility, and spiritual purpose. While implementing this ideal faces significant institutional and cultural challenges, articulating it establishes a vital benchmark for administrative reform, leadership development, and critique of current practices. The study concludes that the treasury of Shiʿi supplications is a fertile and underutilized resource for indigenous managerial ideal-building.
کلیدواژهها English